Imagine dropping by your local thrift store for a quick browse, only to uncover a hidden treasure right in the cash register. That’s exactly what happened to a lucky shopper recently, sparking excitement among coin collectors everywhere. This story isn’t just about a shiny coin—it’s a reminder that everyday spots can hold surprises worth a fortune.
we’ll dive into the details of this incredible discovery, what makes the Susan B. Anthony dollar so special, and tips to spot your own rare finds. If you’re into numismatics (the fancy term for coin collecting), or just love a good underdog story, keep reading.
What Happened at the Thrift Store?
Picture this: It’s a sunny afternoon, and Sarah Jenkins, a 42-year-old teacher from Ohio, pops into her neighborhood Goodwill. She’s hunting for vintage clothes, not valuables. But as she pays for a $5 scarf at the counter, her eyes lock onto a dull silver dollar in the till. The cashier, an elderly volunteer named Tom, shrugs it off as “just loose change.” Sarah, who’s dabbled in coin hunting since her grandpa taught her as a kid, freezes. She politely asks to take a closer look.
That coin? A 1979 Susan B. Anthony dollar in pristine condition—one of the rarest versions out there. Instead of grabbing her scarf and leaving, Sarah haggles a bit and walks away with the coin for a measly $1 extra. Back home, she grabs her magnifying glass and confirms it: This isn’t your average buck. It’s a “clear S” proof variety, minted in San Francisco with a tiny, sharp “S” mint mark that’s super hard to find. Word spread fast on social media, and now Sarah’s story is buzzing in collector forums.
This isn’t the first time thrift stores have coughed up gems. From Civil War-era pennies to misprinted bills, these second-hand havens are goldmines for savvy hunters. But Sarah’s find stands out because Susan B. Anthony dollars are like the quirky cousins of U.S. currency—often overlooked but packed with history and value.
Who Was Susan B. Anthony and Why Her Face on a Dollar?
Let’s break it down simply. Susan B. Anthony was a trailblazing women’s rights activist in the 1800s. She fought hard for women to vote, equal pay, and basic freedoms when those ideas were radical. Born in 1820, she led protests, got arrested for voting illegally in 1872, and never lived to see the 19th Amendment pass in 1920—which finally gave women the vote.
In 1979, the U.S. Mint honored her by putting her face on a new dollar coin. It was meant to be a handy alternative to paper dollars—smaller than the old silver dollars but bigger than quarters. Sadly, it flopped big time. People kept mistaking it for a quarter, and production stopped in 1981 after just a few million were made. Today, most circulate as junk change, but rare ones? They can fetch hundreds or even thousands at auctions.
Fun fact: Anthony’s coin was the first U.S. circulating coin to feature a real woman’s portrait (not a goddess or lady liberty). It paved the way for the Sacagawea dollar in 2000 and even modern designs celebrating diverse heroes.
The Hunt for Rare Susan B. Anthony Dollars: Key Varieties Explained
Not all Susan B. Anthony dollars are created equal. The 1979 clear S proof is a unicorn because the San Francisco Mint goofed—most proofs from that year have a blurry “S” mark from a worn die. Only a tiny batch escaped with a crisp, clear one. Sarah’s coin? It’s graded MS-67 by experts (that’s mint state, meaning near-perfect condition with no big scratches).
To help you spot potentials, here’s a quick table of the top rare varieties, their traits, and rough values based on recent sales from sites like PCGS CoinFacts and eBay auctions (as of September 2025):
| Variety | Year/Mint | Key Feature | Rarity Level | Average Value (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Clear S Proof | 1979-S | Sharp, distinct “S” mint mark on obverse | Extremely Rare (fewer than 1,000 known) | $500–$5,000+ |
| Wide Rim | 1979-P | Thicker edge rim, fewer dents from circulation | Rare | $50–$300 |
| Near Date | 1981-P | Date digits spaced super close together | Uncommon | $20–$150 |
| Filled S Proof | 1981-S | Blurry or “filled” “S” mint mark | Common but undervalued | $5–$50 |
| Deep Cameo Proof | 1999-P | High-contrast design with frosted details | Scarce | $100–$800 |
Note: Values fluctuate with market trends and condition. Always get a professional grading from NGC or PCGS before selling.
If you’re rolling through your change jar, check the date, mint mark (P for Philadelphia, D for Denver, S for San Francisco), and edges. Tools like a 10x loupe (a cheap magnifying tool) can make all the difference.
Why Thrift Stores Are Hotspots for Coin Treasures
Thrift stores like Goodwill or Salvation Army get their cash from donations—old jars, forgotten wallets, you name it. Volunteers often don’t scrutinize every coin, so rarities slip through. Sarah’s story echoes others: In 2023, a Texas flea market vendor found a 1913 Liberty Head nickel (worth $4 million) in a drawer. Closer to home, a 2024 Reddit thread exploded when a user scored a 1909-S VDB Lincoln cent for pennies at a yard sale.
But it’s not all luck. Pros swear by these tips:
- Hit the registers early: Mornings mean fresh till loads.
- Chat up the staff: Friendly volunteers might let you peek.
- Know your stuff: Apps like CoinSnap use your phone’s camera for instant ID.
- Budget smart: Set a $10-per-item limit to avoid impulse buys.
With inflation making headlines, more folks are dumping old change, boosting these finds. Just remember, ethics matter—don’t strong-arm a seller; fair trades keep the hobby fun.
The Bigger Picture: How This Find Inspires Everyday Collectors
Sarah’s tale isn’t just viral fodder; it’s a wake-up call. In a world of digital payments, physical coins tell stories of history, mistakes, and human grit. Anthony’s dollar, born from equality fights, reminds us progress isn’t linear. And for collectors, it’s a thrill—turning pocket lint into portfolio gold.
Sarah plans to auction her coin via Heritage Auctions next month, hoping to fund a family trip. “It’s not about the money,” she says. “It’s the story—proof that wonders hide in plain sight.” Her advice? Start small: Sort your laundry change weekly. You might unearth your own legend.
Conclusion: Your Turn to Hunt for Hidden Gems
From a dusty thrift store drawer to potential auction stardom, Sarah Jenkins’ Susan B. Anthony dollar discovery shows that fortune favors the curious. Whether you’re a history buff, a bargain hunter, or just bored with Netflix, coin collecting offers endless adventure without breaking the bank. Grab a magnifying glass, hit your local spots, and who knows? The next big find could be yours. Remember, every coin has a past—yours might just rewrite the future. Happy hunting!
FAQ: All About Susan B. Anthony Dollars and Rare Coin Finds
What makes a Susan B. Anthony dollar rare?
Rarity comes from minting errors, low production numbers, or perfect condition. The 1979 clear S proof is prized for its sharp mint mark, with only a handful certified.
How can I tell if my dollar coin is valuable?
Check the year (1979–1981 or 1999), mint mark, and condition. Use free apps or online guides, then get it graded by experts like PCGS for an official value.
Are Susan B. Anthony dollars still legal tender?
Yes! They’re worth a dollar in change, but rare ones trade for way more among collectors.
Where’s the best place to find rare coins besides thrift stores?
Try bank rolls (ask for dollar coins), estate sales, flea markets, or even online via eBay—but verify authenticity.
How do I start coin collecting on a budget?
Begin with loose change from daily life. Join free communities like Reddit’s r/coins for tips. Invest in basics: A coin album ($10) and guidebook ($15). Aim for fun over fortune.